Rating ALL of Manchester United's major signings since 2013 | With Jamie Carragher & Gary Neville

47 comentarios en «Rating ALL of Manchester United's major signings since 2013 | With Jamie Carragher & Gary Neville»

1. Fellaini red?? How many has he rescued united.. how can Maguire be any better than Fellaini

2. maguire in amber?? bias towards english players again. he has to be red +

3. Privilege to play for the famous Manchester United once-in-a-lifetime treble winners and in the footsteps of Roger Byrne, Duncan Edwards, Nobby Stiles, Harry Gregg, Bill Foulkes, Denis Violett, Paddy Crerand, Alex Stepney, Best, Law, Charlton, Buchan, Gordon Hill, Coppull, Gary Bailey, Macari, McIlroy, Stapelton, Whiteside, Kanchelskis, Mark Hughes, Denis Irwin, Ince, Bruce, Pallister, Schmeichel, Robson, Cantona, Keane, Carrick, Butt, Edwin vSar, Evra, Vidic, Japp Stam, Ferdinand, Ji-Sung-Park, Beckham, Giggs, Scholes, vNistelrooy, Yorke, Cole, Sheringham and-Solskjaer-has-won-it, vPersie, Rooney, Ronaldo, DeGea.

4. Mata, Martial = Umber…. Maguire, Fred = Red

5. How had maguire and Shaw been in the Amber category maguire hs been shocking for 3 years people are acting like it's just last season he was awful tye season before and average at best in his first season. Season before last was when maguire pulled down Shaw in that 6.1 battering. Shaw has been there 8 years or so. Neve rooks after his body overweight for a footballer and his body is made out of biscuits because of it shows had 1 amazing season.

   Fact is maguire cost 80 million aswel u should have an isolated category for him alone.

   I can't stand pogba but he was way better then maguire and has done some amazing stuff in a United shirt maguire calls for hand balls against his own players fouls his own players man's literally playing against us

6. Sancho??

7. Herrera and Maguire in the same category… You should smoke less weed guys.

8. Maguire is same level as Hazard to Real. Absolutely terrible.

9. Be interested to know why Gary thinks Herrera is only an Amber (considering he was less than £30m)

10. Absolutely pathetic list and concept, one of the worst videos Neville and Carra have made.

11. Those catas

12. stopped watching the moment I saw Maguire and shaw in amber and not in red. lolol. varane and telles have done better but they are in red 🙄. what a joke.

13. Maguire should be in green 😐 neville doesn't know anything about ball

14. Ronaldo needs to go

15. They put harry mcretard in amber… have they forgotten what football means?

16. Why is Dan James red?? That’s ridiculous. Came as a young lad, didn’t quite make it, went for more than 10 million profit. Making him red is very harsh.

17. No wonder why Gary Neville failed at Valencia

18. Cavani should be amber …he only left bc of Ronaldo
    The jury is still out on Varane & Sancho

19. Maguire is Man Utd's version of Jamaal Lascelles, great potential when they were young but not consistent or sho enough quality but both clubs are hesitant to move them on

20. whole season under ETH before being appropriately judged.

21. Does anyone know where Gary stands on the Glazers?

22. Martial does not belong in the red tier.

23. 3:07 Liverpool mate, easy work!

24. whole season under ETH before being appropriately judged.

25. Pogba, Blind and mata should be in Amber.

    Maguire should have his own category below red

26. You cannot keep blaming the glazers, they have spent the money since fergie has left. However the managers since then have brought all different players in. Mourinho first windows was a good, Van Gaal made some good signings, ole brought too much british. pundits dont help, Carragher is the only one who is not biased. Neville , Scholes , Rio are all putting thier 5p in and not helping. Let the manager have his own identity, Fergie needs to stay away and just be a fan instead of hanging around like a bad smell. I also think that the best way for United is to sell players who do not want to buy into the managers methods, It happened with Rangnick

27. Maguire should be Red and Mata Amber. They're the only two I disagree with.

28. why is maguire not on the black

29. I’d put Harry Maguire in the red for sure he’s been the worst signing out of all of them. mata was okay he’s amber ronaldo got you top 6 last season single handedly without him they would of been in the bottom half of the table so it’s criminal how he’s anything other then green despite his behaviour of late which is understandable as he’s frustrated at what he’s getting and playing with the players around him.

    Van de beek doesn’t get played so doesn’t have a chance.

30. They could just defeat Liverpool and we could see Gary taking a U turn once again. 😄

31. Lukaku in red? He scored tons of goals.. still a mistery to me why they got rid of him

32. Maguire amber ???

33. Luke Shaw is amber? Are they evaluating his performance at the club buffet?

34. Shaw and Maguire are both terrible.

35. Dan James is Green, made big profit on him

36. Total self fulfilling prophecy

37. Absolutely horrific punditry here

38. Fellaini should be at least amber, had some very positive moments and all managers rated him.

39. Why does ronaldo get so much hate

40. So there's Green, Amber, Red….
    But a separate category untold here….only one player is in it.
    Crossing the road and getting smashed, Harry Maguire.

41. The reason United are so poor is because they keep on overrating players. Fred, McTominay, Sancho, Bissaka, Shaw & Maguire are overrated.

42. from nothing.

43. This shows, specially to me, that is less about the signings and more about how you handle these signings and how you build the club –
    Most of those players are incredibly valuable outside of Utd

44. ‘Special measures’ 🥴 👶🏻 😂😂😂😂

45. Truth is Man Utd havent made a single bad signing…. its just Man Utd make bad players….. all these World Class Players would have smashed it at Liverpool and City…

46. Lukaku in red?? He was at Man Utd for only 2 seasons and scored 27 goals in all comps in his first, and almost single handedly knocked PSG out of the champions league with 2 goals in Man Utds greatest ever 2nd leg comeback. He literally cost the same as Maguire…..

    Ronaldo almost got the golden boot at 37 years old in the worst Utd side in premier league history….

    Dont even think this video is worth watching. What a mess.

47. The more I hear Neville talk about football and other players, the more I'm convinced his successful career has to be completely credited to Alex Ferguson's brilliance.

Los comentarios están cerrados.